Vintage under $500

Shy Creation (182)

Vintage Collection (571)

Watches (24)

Sort

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Clear all

193 Results

Clear all

Vintage knot studs

$270.00

Unit price: per

$270.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage "gavel" charm

$210.00

Unit price: per

$210.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Ann Allen earrings

$175.00

Unit price: per

$175.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage bar-link chain

$355.00

Unit price: per

$355.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage diamond band

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage locket & cross

$240.00

Unit price: per

$240.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage amethyst ring

$495.00

Unit price: per

$495.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage light jade ring

$470.00

Unit price: per

$470.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage heart pendant

$425.00

Unit price: per

$425.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage sapphire cluster

$375.00

Unit price: per

$375.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage pearl ring

$340.00

Unit price: per

$340.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage onyx beads

$155.00

Unit price: per

$155.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Bunny bookmark

$160.00

Unit price: per

$160.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Small Vintage cluster ring

$495.00

Unit price: per

$495.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage tanzanite ring

$410.00

Unit price: per

$410.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Star of David

$240.00

Unit price: per

$240.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Starfish earrings

$485.00

Unit price: per

$485.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Miraculous medal

$490.00

Unit price: per

$490.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Miraculous medal

$320.00

Unit price: per

$320.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage engraved cross

$240.00

Unit price: per

$240.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage diamond cross

$445.00

Unit price: per

$445.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage tube cross

$325.00

Unit price: per

$325.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage oval locket

$420.00

Unit price: per

$420.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage garnet cross

$295.00

Unit price: per

$295.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Starfish pendant

$325.00

Unit price: per

$325.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Big Ben charm

$390.00

Unit price: per

$390.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage turtle charm

$155.00

Unit price: per

$155.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Lion charm

$495.00

Unit price: per

$495.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage puffy earrings

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage pearl halo ring

$240.00

Unit price: per

$240.00

Unit price: per

In stock

VIntage pearl necklace

$375.00

Unit price: per

$375.00

Unit price: per

In stock

SS 23" VINTAGE JOHN HARDY TEAR

$410.00

Unit price: per

$410.00

Unit price: per

In stock

20% off

Vintage ruby dome ring

Regular price ~~$560.00~~ $448.00

Unit price: per

Regular price ~~$560.00~~ $448.00

Unit price: per

In stock

14KY GOLD 18" VINTAGE 1" STRIP

$255.00

Unit price: per

$255.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage diamond-cut hoops

$225.00

Unit price: per

$225.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage 14k/silver drops

$250.00

Unit price: per

$250.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage pearl cluster earrings

$475.00

Unit price: per

$475.00

Unit price: per

In stock

20% off

14KW GOLD VINTAGE SYNTHETIC BA

Regular price ~~$425.00~~ $340.00

Unit price: per

Regular price ~~$425.00~~ $340.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Peruvian drops

$340.00

Unit price: per

$340.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage curly drops

$420.00

Unit price: per

$420.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage cluster pendant

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage knot ring

$360.00

Unit price: per

$360.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage blue topaz ring

$430.00

Unit price: per

$430.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage 2-opal drops

$350.00

Unit price: per

$350.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage 1.5" hoops

$250.00

Unit price: per

$250.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Rolling ring

$480.00

Unit price: per

$480.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage mabe enhancer

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage micro cross

$295.00

Unit price: per

$295.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Tiffany beads

$350.00

Unit price: per

$350.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage filigree earrings

$495.00

Unit price: per

$495.00

Unit price: per

In stock

You're viewing 51-100 of 193 products

Explore More

Looking for something else?

Shop all

New

Vintage sapphire ring

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

1969 Rolex President

$13,500.00

Unit price: per

$13,500.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Vintage 1ct diamond cross

$995.00

Unit price: per

$995.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Vintage wire knot studs

$170.00

Unit price: per

$170.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Fancu Vintage ruby cross

$395.00

Unit price: per

$395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Vintage pearl ring

$290.00

Unit price: per

$290.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

14KY GOLD 18" ROUND ANTIQUE LO

$625.00

Unit price: per

$625.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Wide sapphire ring

$1,395.00

Unit price: per

$1,395.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Vintage prasiolite

$1,495.00

Unit price: per

$1,495.00

Unit price: per

In stock

New

Vintage diamond solitaire

$1,100.00

Unit price: per

$1,100.00

Unit price: per

In stock

Vintage Collection

Shy Creation

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Explore More

Looking for something else?

Featured Collections

Sign up for our Newsletter